Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Water Heater: Which Is Better?

When upgrading a water heater, most homeowners hit the same fork in the road: a tankless water heater, indoor or outdoor.

On paper, both promise endless hot water and lower energy use. However,  in real life, placement makes a big difference. It dictates your installation costs and how long the unit stays healthy. 

Unfortunately, most people don’t know what to prioritise between the tankless indoor vs outdoor water heater setup. Most assume all systems are the same as long as they deliver hot water.

This assumption sees most people ending up with higher costs, inconvenient maintenance, or a unit that doesn’t handle climate well.

If choosing between an indoor vs outdoor on-demand water heater gives you trouble, this guide is here to help. It will explain how these two systems compare and ultimately help you pick the best one for your location, household, and daily hot water needs.

Should I Choose an Indoor or an Outdoor Tankless Water Heater

When upgrading your hot water for the first time, most people ask, “Which is better, an indoor or an outdoor tankless water heater?” The straightforward answer is that the best option depends on your use case and your local weather.

🟩 Best for New Builds

If you are starting from scratch, an indoor unit is the way to go. You can plan the indoor tankless water heater ventilation needs early.

It is easier to run the proper gas lines and stainless steel flues while the walls are open. Since the unit lives inside, you won’t have to worry about the home’s exterior look.

🟩 Best for Cold Climates

If you live in cold areas like Tasmania and are stuck between indoor vs outdoor tankless water heaters for cold climates, the indoor model is a clear winner. It stays tucked away in a heated space.

This avoids the outdoor tankless water heater freezing issues that can crack a heat exchanger in a single night.

🟩 Best for Warm Climates

In the south, an outdoor tankless water heater for home use is often the best. You don’t have to worry about venting or stealing closet space. These units thrive in mild weather and are much cheaper to install since they don’t need a chimney.

🟩 Best for Tighter Spaces

When every square foot counts, go for the outdoor models, especially if you have a balcony. If not, look for a small “point-of-use” indoor model. Moving the heater to an exterior wall frees up an entire utility closet for storage.

Indoor Tankless Water Heater Installation Requirements

Indoor systems usually have more installation requirements because of venting and clearances.

Outdoor units need fewer parts but must be securely mounted and protected. Here is a quick breakdown of how indoor vs outdoor tankless water heater installation requirements compare: 

🟩 Indoor tankless water heater installation requirements:  If you decide to work from the inside, you have to take into consideration the space requirements for an indoor tankless water heater.

It needs at least 12 inches of clearance at the top and bottom, and about 6 inches on the sides to “breathe” and stay accessible for repairs. You must also consider the indoor tankless water heater ventilation needs to ensure safety.

The venting requires a dedicated exhaust path to the outside, often using specialised stainless steel or PVC pipes, depending on the model’s efficiency rating.

Without a proper vent, dangerous fumes can linger in your home, so getting this part right is non-negotiable for a safe house.

🟩 Outdoor tankless water heater installation requirements: These units are built to be self-sufficient on an exterior wall.

The space requirement for outdoor tankless water heater wall mounting is usually minimal, though the wall must be sturdy enough to handle the weight and heat. The best part is that the outdoor instantaneous water heater ventilation needs are simple.

Since the unit lives in the open air, it vents its exhaust directly through a front-facing grate. You won’t have to worry about cutting massive holes in your roof or running expensive pipes through your attic.

Tip: Always confirm the local code before installation. Some towns have very specific rules about how close an outdoor vent can be to a window or an air intake.

Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Water Heater in Cold Weather

When comparing indoor vs outdoor tankless water heaters for chilly areas, the indoor tankless water heater for winter climates takes the crown. It is the safest bet because it is physically shielded from the biting wind and sub-zero nights.

While modern outdoor models are tough, they are inherently more vulnerable when the temperature drops. 

Here is why an outdoor instantaneous water heater may struggle in cold weather: 

• Outdoor tankless water heater freezing issues: When the mercury drops, water sitting in the heat exchanger can turn to ice. Because ice expands, it can crack the internal copper pipes, leading to a massive leak once it thaws.
• The “Sitting Duck” Factor: Most outdoor units have electric anti-freeze heaters. However, if a winter storm knocks out your power, these safety features stop working. In a place like the Blue Mountains or Ballarat, a single night without power can destroy an unprotected outdoor unit.
• Efficiency Loss: In an indoor vs outdoor tankless water heater comparison, the outdoor unit has a harder start. It has to heat water that might be near 0°C while sitting in a freezing breeze, which can slightly slow down how fast you get hot water at the tap.
• Extra weather protection required: To prevent these headaches, you’ll need to invest in heat tape and quality pipe insulation for all exposed plumbing. While outdoor tankless water heater weather protection, like a recess box, helps, it isn’t a total shield against a proper Aussie frost.

Maintenance Cost Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Water Heater

When comparing the maintenance costs for indoor vs outdoor on-demand water heaters, the outdoor model needs more of your attention. It is always exposed to the wild Aussie weather, so it faces a tougher life than one tucked away in a dry laundry room.

While both types require regular descaling and filter cleaning to handle our often “hard” water, the maintenance cost of indoor vs outdoor tankless water heaters starts to show in the physical upkeep:

• Outdoor Units: These need frequent checks for spider webs, wasp nests, and dust buildup in the intake. In coastal areas like Sydney or Perth, salt air can lead to corrosion, requiring you to clean the casing more often to protect your investment.
• Indoor Units: Since they live in a temperature-controlled bubble, the internal components tend to stay pristine. You mostly just need to focus on descaling the heat exchanger once a year to keep that efficiency high.

To extend the reliability of your indoor or outdoor tankless system, make sure you’re flushing the unit to remove mineral scale. If you skip this, the heat exchanger has to work harder, which can lead to a shorter lifespan and higher gas bills.

Efficiency Difference Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless

Indoor units are usually slightly more efficient than outdoor instantaneous water heaters, and it is easy to see why. For one, the indoor model is physically shielded by your home’s insulation, meaning it doesn’t lose much heat to the surrounding air.

When the air inside your house is at a steady room temperature, the unit’s internal components stay warm, allowing it to reach your target heat faster and with less fuel.

Outdoor units are still incredibly efficient by modern Australian standards, but they do face a bit more of an uphill battle. Because they are hanging on an exterior wall, they are constantly exposed to the ambient temperature.

If it’s a cold night in Melbourne or Adelaide, the unit has to work harder to heat up its own internal pipes and heat exchanger before it can even get to work on your water.

This creates a tiny amount of heat loss that indoor models simply don’t have to deal with.

To get the most out of whichever system you choose, keep these factors in mind:

• Proximity: Install the unit as close to your most-used taps as possible. This stops energy from being wasted as hot water travels through meters of cold pipes in your walls.
• Insulation: If you go with an outdoor model, wrapping your external copper pipes in thick foam is a must to keep that heat from vanishing into the night.
• Climate Choice: In the tropical north of Australia, the efficiency gap is basically non-existent. However, in the cooler southern states, an indoor unit will generally save you more on your gas bill over the long run.

Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Water Heater Lifespan

The lifespan of an indoor vs outdoor tankless water heater varies by exposure. Indoor units often last 20+ years. Outdoor units average 12–15 years with protection. Weather, freezing, and airflow affect durability.

Typical lifespan

• Indoor Units: 20+ years
  
• Outdoor Units: 12–15 years with protection
  

Indoor Tankless Water Heater Safety Concerns

Safety is the biggest priority when installing an indoor or outdoor tankless water heater. Indoor tankless water heater safety concerns focus on clearance and ventilation.

You can’t just tuck these units into a tight cupboard and forget about them.

They need a specific amount of breathing room, usually 300mm at the top and bottom, to keep the heat from building up and to ensure a plumber can actually reach the parts for a service.

Proper airflow prevents exhaust buildup. Because the unit burns gas, it produces combustion by-products. If your venting isn’t spot on, you risk carbon monoxide leaking into your home.

Under Australian Standards (AS/NZS 5601.1), indoor units must be room-sealed or have a dedicated flue to carry those fumes safely outside.

Outdoor units face outdoor tankless water heater exposure risks like moisture and debris.

Rain, dust, and even local pests like spiders building nests in the vents can cause the system to fail or corrode. While they don’t need complex indoor flue pipes, they must be mounted away from windows so the exhaust doesn’t drift back into your living room.

Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Water Heater for Small Home

• Small Apartment: For a small home or apartment, every square metre counts. Choosing an “indoor vs outdoor tankless for apartments” setup usually comes down to where you can afford to lose space. Indoor units are great because they keep your exterior walls clean and are tucked away in a laundry or cupboard. But if your place is truly tiny, moving the unit outside frees up that precious storage space inside.

• Large Households: Large families have different needs. If you’ve got back-to-back showers and a dishwasher running, you need power. “Indoor vs outdoor tankless for large family homes” depends entirely on your peak demand. Often, a high-capacity indoor system is better in cooler states like Victoria because it doesn’t have to work as hard to heat up from a freezing start. However, if you have a massive house with plenty of sunny wall space, an outdoor unit is often easier to install without messing with your interior floor plan.

• Commercials: For shops or offices, the indoor vs outdoor tankless for commercial use decision is usually driven by the building’s layout. If you’re in a high-rise office, an indoor unit is often the only choice due to venting access. In a standalone workshop or a cafe with an alleyway, an outdoor unit is much simpler and cheaper to maintain. It really just depends on whether you have a safe spot outside that’s sheltered from the worst of the weather.

Pro Tip: If you’re in a tight apartment, look for “recess boxes.” These allow an outdoor unit to sit flush inside the wall, giving you the best of both worlds—saved space inside and a clean look outside.

Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Water Heater: Quick Comparison

To help you understand the comparison between these two setups better, here is a quick overview of an indoor tankless water heater compared to an outdoor one.

Feature	Indoor Tankless Water Heater	Outdoor Tankless Water Heater
Venting Needs	Complex flues through the roof/wall	Self-venting (built-in grates)
Climate Fit	Ideal for cold, frosty regions	Best for mild or tropical areas
Space Impact	Uses a closet or utility room	Frees up all internal storage
Install Cost	Higher (pipes + labor)	Lower (no chimney needed)
Weather Risk	Safe from wind and rain	Risk of freezing or corrosion
Average Lifespan	20+ years	15–20 years

Making the Final Call: Indoor vs Outdoor Tankless Hot Water System

Choosing between an indoor and an outdoor tankless water heater usually comes down to your home’s layout and the local weather. The main difference between indoor and outdoor tankless water heater setups is where they breathe and how they handle the elements.

Indoor units are tucked inside, providing great protection but requiring a complex venting process to send exhaust outside. Outdoor units mount on your exterior walls. They face the wild weather but offer a much simpler installation that skips the need for expensive chimneys.

FAQs